A US district court has sought assistance from three Delhi district courts—Patiala House, Dwarka, and Tis Hazari—to serve summons on National Security Advisor Ajit Doval and former Research and Analysis Wing (R&AW) chief Samant Goel in Gurpatwant Singh Pannun‘s civil lawsuit alleging a 2023 assassination plot. Reports published on November 19, 2026, follow orders issued by US District Judge Katherine Polk Failla in the Southern District of New York after earlier service attempts did not succeed.
The development centers on a civil damages claim filed by Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, founder and general counsel of the banned group Sikhs for Justice (SFJ), rather than a criminal arrest warrant. While the procedural move keeps the Pannun civil lawsuit active in New York, it also tests established questions of cross-border legal procedure, sovereign immunity, and diplomatic protocol between Washington and New Delhi.
Why The US Court Turned To Three Delhi Courts
Earlier efforts to serve Ajit Doval and Samant Goel personally in the United States or through India’s designated central authority under the Hague Convention ran into roadblocks. Court records indicate that earlier requests routed through India’s Ministry of Law and Justice were returned on the ground that the summons were not covered under the Hague Convention.
To move past that impasse, Judge Katherine Polk Failla looked to Article 19 of the Hague Convention, which permits service of foreign judicial documents through methods allowed under the domestic law of the receiving state. Pannun’s legal team pointed to Section 29(c) of India’s Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) and a January 2009 notification, alongside Order V rules governing the transmission and return of court summons.
“Requests for serving of judicial documents in India can only be routed through India’s designated central authority, that is, the Ministry of Law and Justice.” — Randhir Jaiswal, Ministry of External Affairs spokesperson, November 10, 2026
Under the court’s timeline, Pannun’s side was directed to submit a proposed service packet by November 30, 2026, after which the clerk of court is to arrange transmission of the judicial documents to the designated courts in Delhi via international mail or courier. Judge Failla also left open the possibility of revisiting the question if Indian authorities submit a formal clarification or objection.
Civil Lawsuit Context And Separate Criminal Proceedings
Pannun filed his civil suit in September 2024, naming the Government of India, Ajit Doval, Samant Goel, Vikash Yadav (also referenced as Vikram Yadav), Nikhil Gupta, and unnamed defendants in connection with an alleged 2023 plot to kill him in New York. The allegations in the civil suit remain unproven claims in court, and questions of legal service and sovereign immunity remain subject to judicial determination.
This civil action is legally distinct from separate US criminal proceedings over the alleged murder-for-hire plot. The US Justice Department charged former government-affiliated official Vikash Yadav in October 2024, while Nikhil Gupta pleaded guilty in February 2026.
Legal observers emphasize that Gupta’s guilty plea applies to the criminal case against him and does not establish civil liability against Ajit Doval, Samant Goel, or the Government of India. Nor does a procedural order authorizing an alternative route for US court Delhi courts summons delivery equate to a finding of guilt or an arrest order against any Indian official.
India’s Position And Diplomatic Stakes
India has consistently rejected the allegations in the lawsuit as fabricated, malicious, and baseless. In October 2024, India’s Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) stated that Vikash Yadav was no longer a government employee and announced a committee to examine evidence and issues raised by US authorities regarding the alleged plot.
On the procedural question, New Delhi maintains that foreign judicial requests in India belong exclusively with the Department of Legal Affairs under the Ministry of Law and Justice, which serves as India’s designated central authority under the Hague Convention. New Delhi has also previously objected to direct service methods under Article 10 of the Hague Convention, while the US State Department took no position on using Indian courts for individual service under this alternative route.
The dispute echoes past friction when civil lawsuits were filed in US courts against Indian leaders by SFJ, including a 2013 civil summons incident involving then-Prime Minister Manmohan Singh. Even when plaintiffs seek to invoke domestic procedures like Section 29(c) of the CPC, actual execution and legal effect inside India depend on how Indian courts and authorities handle foreign judicial requests.
| Key Aspect | Current Status / Details |
|---|---|
| Presiding Judge & Court | Judge Katherine Polk Failla, US District Court for the Southern District of New York |
| Named Individual Officials | NSA Ajit Doval and former R&AW chief Samant Goel (in Pannun’s civil suit) |
| Indian Courts Identified | Patiala House Court, Dwarka Court, and Tis Hazari Court in Delhi |
| Legal Provisions Cited | Article 19 of the Hague Convention; Section 29(c) and Order V of India’s CPC |
| Key Upcoming Deadline | November 30, 2026 for submitting the proposed service packet |
| Nature of Proceeding | Civil damages lawsuit; allegations are unproven and not a criminal arrest warrant |
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why did the US court ask Delhi courts to help with the summons?
The court approved an alternative route under Article 19 of the Hague Convention and Section 29(c) of India’s Code of Civil Procedure after earlier service attempts did not succeed.
2. Does this order mean Ajit Doval or Samant Goel can be arrested or found liable?
No, this is a procedural step in a civil lawsuit—not a criminal arrest warrant or a ruling on the merits of the allegations.
3. What is India’s official stance on serving foreign summons in this case?
India has rejected the lawsuit’s allegations as baseless and maintains that judicial service requests in India can only be routed through the Ministry of Law and Justice as the designated central authority.
4. What happens next after the November 30, 2026 deadline?
Once Pannun submits the proposed service packet by November 30, 2026, the court clerk is set to arrange transmission to the three Delhi courts, subject to further court review and any formal input or objections raised.
5. Is this civil lawsuit the same case as Nikhil Gupta’s criminal case in the US?
No, Pannun’s civil damages suit is separate from the US criminal prosecution involving Nikhil Gupta and Vikash Yadav.
What Happens Next And Long-Term Implications
In the near term, attention centers on November 30, 2026, when proposed service documents are due, and on how the New York court handles transmission to Delhi’s Patiala House, Dwarka, and Tis Hazari courts. Any formal clarification or objection from Indian authorities could also prompt the court to revisit the service question.
Over the longer term, the case highlights a recurring friction point in transnational litigation: foreign litigants attempting to use domestic statutory hooks under Article 19 of the Hague Convention while sovereign states insist on strict adherence to central-authority channels and sovereign immunity doctrines. For India-US relations, managing security cooperation and accountability narratives alongside sensitive judicial filings will remain a delicate balancing act.
Manish Kumar began his professional journey in digital marketing and performance marketing, and currently works as a Digital Marketing Excutive and SEO expert. With over 3 years of professional experience, he handles both strategy and execution. Currently, he manages digital marketing and performance marketing at ‘Shabd Sanchi’ (shabdsanchi.com).

